Judges from Britain’s highest court have been doing double duty on Hong Kong’s since 1997. But this legacy of the city’s past will not feature in its future
Save time by listening to our audio articles as you multitaskTo anyone unfamiliar with Hong Kong’s tangled history, this may seem odd. But judges from Britain’s highest court have been doing double duty on Hong Kong’s since 1997 as part of the deal that handed the city from Britain to China.
This legacy of Hong Kong’s past will not feature in its future, though. On March 30th Lord Reed and his colleague, Lord Hodge, resigned from Hong Kong’s top court. No other serving British judge will be allowed to succeed them. According to Liz Truss, Britain’s foreign secretary, a national-security law imposed on Hong Kong in 2020 has exerted a “far-reaching chilling effect”. To stay on the top court “would risk legitimising oppression”, she said.
In commercial cases and ordinary criminal cases Hong Kong courts remain independent, says a British barrister who appears before them. But the national-security law has nonetheless had an “insidious effect”. Ambitious judges “are not going to deliver rulings that displease Beijing”. This is true even in cases that are not tried under the national-security law, but are politically charged.
That puts the foreigners on the bench in a tricky position. Hong Kong welcomes judges from common-law jurisdictions—and it has attracted some of the world’s best. Such minds would improve any judiciary. The fact they could resign may also serve as a deterrent, preventing officials in Beijing from meddling more than they do. But by hanging around, foreign judges could also make it seem as if little has changed in Hong Kong. Their presence makes the courts better than they would otherwise be.
Even now, some judicial links with Britain remain. Six retired British judges still serve on the top court; others appear elsewhere in the system. And because the legal system has English roots, cases still sometimes cite English precedents. Mr Leung’s defence referred to the bill of rights passed in England in 1689.
Brasil Últimas Notícias, Brasil Manchetes
Similar News:Você também pode ler notícias semelhantes a esta que coletamos de outras fontes de notícias.
Swedish court dishes out justice after judge steals meatballsSupreme court justice was fined 50,000 kronor after she was caught trying to hide a number of food items in Stockholm
Consulte Mais informação »
Judge upholds Ghislaine Maxwell's sex trafficking conviction despite juror's revelationsA judge has upheld British socialite Ghislaine Maxwell's conviction for sex trafficking despite a juror's revelations that followed the trial.
Consulte Mais informação »
Roy Reynolds: 'Barbaric murder' of man found in Carrickfergus reservoirThe body of 54-year-old Roy Reynolds was found in North Woodburn Reservoir on Monday.
Consulte Mais informação »
Brighton v Norwich: match previewBrighton and Norwich, the two sides at the bottom of the top-flight form table, meet with both hoping to end six-match losing runs
Consulte Mais informação »
Appeal filed for ex-clerk who refused marriage licensesAttorneys for a former Kentucky clerk who wouldn’t issue marriage licenses to two same-sex couples have appealed a federal court ruling that she violated the couples’ constitutional rights
Consulte Mais informação »